New York

Supreme Court rules for NY coronavirus restrictions

Washington (AP) — As the coronavirus case surges nationwide again, late Wednesday the Supreme Court forced New York to enforce certain attendance restrictions at places of worship in areas designated as being hit hard by the virus. Temporarily banned.

A court proceeding may allow New York to reassess these restrictions. However, the proceedings in court will not be immediately affected, as the two groups sued as a result of the restrictions, the Roman Catholic Church in Brooklyn and Queens and the Orthodox Jewish synagogue, are no longer the subject of them.

The group challenged the restrictions on attendance at places of worship in the areas designated in the red and orange zones, where New York restricted attendance to 10 and 25, respectively. However, because the group is in the area designated as the Yellow Zone, it is subject to the relaxed rules.

Judges have split into 5-4, currently banning the state from enforcing restrictions on the group, with new judge Amy Coney Barrett making up the majority. This was the first vote as a judge publicly recognized by the Conservative Party. Three liberal judges in the court and Supreme Court judge John Roberts objected.

The judge acted in an emergency while the proceedings disputing the restrictions continued. In an unsigned order, a majority of courts said the restrictions “chosen places of worship for particularly harsh treatment.”

This move was a court shift. Earlier this year, when Barrett’s liberal predecessor, Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg, appeared in court, the judge split 5 to 4 and had a pandemic-related capacity affecting churches in California and Nevada. I left the limit.

The court proceeding was the victory of the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Jewish synagogue, which challenged the state restrictions announced by Governor Andrew Cuomo on October 6.

The Brooklyn Diocese, which covers Brooklyn and Queens, claimed that the place of worship was unfairly selected by the governor’s executive order. In the Red Zone, businesses that are considered “essential”, from grocery stores to pet stores, said they could continue to operate without capacity limits, although “non-essential” businesses had to be closed. It was. And in the Orange Zone, most companies can open without capacity limits.

The parish claimed that it was previously operated safely by limiting attendance to 25% of the building’s capacity and taking other steps. Part of Brooklyn and Queens is now in the Yellow Zone, and attendance at the place of worship is limited to 50 percent of the building’s capacity.

Agdas Israel of America, an orthodox Jewish organization with synagogues affected by the restrictions, also sued. The organization argued that the governor’s restrictions specifically targeted the Orthodox Jewish community.

As part of that, New York told the court that religious rallies were less restrictive than secular rallies with the same risk of infection, which were completely banned, such as concerts and plays.

Two lower courts upheld New York by allowing them to maintain place of worship restrictions. According to state websites that track hotspot-designated areas, there are currently some areas throughout the state that have orange zones, but no red zones.

Supreme Court rules for NY coronavirus restrictions

Source link Supreme Court rules for NY coronavirus restrictions

Back to top button