Laurel Hubbard’s first transgender Olympic backlash

new Zealand Weightlifter Laurel Hubbard made history on Sunday when she was first openly elected as a transgender athlete. OlympicBut those who are fighting to keep biological men away from women’s sports say she only proves their claim.

At the age of 43 Hubbard Almost twice as old as She Competitors. She At the age of 35, he moved to the top ranks of international women’s weightlifting after a solid yet brilliant career as a junior male lifter.

She Encouraged to join the super heavyweight New Zealand Olympic team and call Fairplay for Women, despite suffering an injury that could end his career in 2018 She An example of a textbook “Why women’s sports must be booked only for women’s gender”.

“Think for a moment,” the British group tweeted. “A testosterone-fuel [sic] Puberty offers enormous physical benefits in weightlifting, so someone can still qualify for the women’s category Olympic After breaking his arm at the age of 43. “

New Zealand Olympic Committee on Sunday Ms. Hubbard Prior to the Tokyo Olympics, which will be held from July 23 to August, a weightlifting team consisting of five members won the spot. 8.8.

“what Olympic Not only is it shameful that men are doing it by allowing them to compete in the women’s category, but it’s also a ridicule of sports, “said Beth Stelzer, president of Save Women’s Sports. “Women’s rights should not end where the emotions of a few men begin.”

new Zealand Officials are Ms. Hubbard met International Olympic Committee And by maintaining the standards of the International Weightlifting Federation She serum testosterone Declares levels of less than 10 nanomoles per liter for at least 12 months before competition She Gender identity as a woman for at least 4 years.

“Not only one of the best companies in the world She Events, Laurel meet IWF eligibility criteria, including those based on IOC “Guidelines for Consensus Statements for Transgender Athletes,” said Kalein Smith, CEO of NZOC. “We recognize that gender identity in sports is a very sensitive and complex issue that requires a balance between human rights and fairness in the arena.”

However, from a public relations point of view, Mr. Hubbard Not an ideal barrier breaker.

“What a pitiful day in the history of women’s sports!” Lindablade, a former Canadian track champion and author of the newly released book, said, “Stop Sport: Transgender Activities and Science. How denial is destroying sports. “

“It’s totally sneaky,” Blade said in an email. “This is not a way to be” inclusive “or” fair. ” “

Mark House, a US lawyer and IWF Category 2 technician, is Ms. Hubbard Refuse the chance to participate in the Tokyo Olympics and warn She Will retreat the causes of transgender athletes in particular She Medal.

Laurel Hubbard Do defenders want to be the face of transgender policy? ” he It was essayed at Inside the Games on May 30th. “The question is rhetorical because the answer is clearly” no. “Have an individual who spends most She As the face of the movement, the adult life as a man transitioning at age 35 will certainly be catastrophic, as actual transgender policies have come into force and are being considered. “

he Said She The best finish as a junior men’s weightlifter would have been enough to win the last few US Junior National Tournaments, but “I couldn’t get a position on the international team.

“In short, Laurel was talented before the transition, but he wasn’t the best athlete in the world,” House said.

MS. HubbardHas avoided interviews for the past few years, said later She That choice She “I am humbled by the kindness and support I have received from so many New Zealanders.

“When I broke my arm at the Commonwealth Games three years ago, I was told that my sports career probably came to an end.” She Said in a statement. “But your support, your encouragement … brought me into the darkness.”

LGBTQ supporters line up behind Ms. Hubbard, Some people IOC In 2003, we approved guidelines for transgender participation from men to women, but it took nearly 20 years for such athletes to first form a team.

“Transclusion Guidelines Olympic Carefully researched, created and implemented, transgender people have never competed. Olympic.. The standards are incredibly high, “said transgender activist Charlotte Clymer. “I support you Laurel Hubbard So She Make history. “

LGBTQ Group Athlete Ally said, “For the first time, you’ll see transgender athletes competing in #Olympics. new ZealandLaurel Hubbard.. “

At least two biological women identified as non-binary or transgender are expected to participate Olympic — At a women’s sporting event — But. Hubbard So far, it is the only male-to-female competitor to play against women.

The other two male-to-female Olympic applicants, both Americans, are unlikely to take action in Tokyo.

Last week, US cyclist Chelsea Wolfe, 28, was selected as a replacement player for the US BMX freestyle team. Meanwhile, 26-year-old hurdle Sesetelfer is the first male-to-female transgender athlete to win the NCAA title for women. To qualify for this week’s Olympic track and field.

Meanwhile, opposition to male-to-female athletes like Mr. Hubbard, who competes with biological women, has increased. Concerned women in the United States called Mr Hubbard’s choice “just another example of a movement governing body that denies women’s equal rights.”

“There are immutable biological differences between male and female bodies whose transgender identities do not disappear,” said the conservative group. “By ignoring this, these athletic organizations deny Olympic female athletes the safety, opportunity, and fair competition they deserve to appease the awakened Left.”

Mary Kate Fein, communication director of the feminist Women’s Liberation movement, said: Laurel HubbardCompete in, man, new Zealand A women’s weightlifting team in Tokyo.

“By forcing people his The road to a women’s league, primarily based on the arbitrary characteristics of “gender identity” Committee It set a dangerous precedent that could undo decades of progress towards women’s movement equality, “fein said in an email.

Kara Dansky, chairman of the U.S. branch of the Women’s Human Rights Campaign, said, “The organization is categorically opposed to Hubbard’s participation in the women’s weightlifting category simply because Hubbard is not a woman. ..

IOC We must revise our policy of allowing men to compete as women, “Dancey said.

This problem IOC Already wrestling with another controversial gender issue: the status of South African runner Caster Semenya. testosterone level.

Gold medalists at the 2012 and 2016 Olympics were banned from World Athletics in the 400-meter to 1-mile race in 2018. testosterone-Lower the drug she refused to do. She appealed the decision to the European Court of Human Rights.

Sign up for our daily newsletter

Laurel Hubbard’s first transgender Olympic backlash

Source link Laurel Hubbard’s first transgender Olympic backlash

Back to top button