Asian students lose out in New York City’s new school admissions system

Asian students were the biggest losers below New raffle entry rules For public high schools that minimize the importance of good grades — New Ministry of Education, where 30% of applicants fit none of the top five options data Reveal.

Of the 12,082 Asians who applied for freshman seats at city schools in the fall, only 8,484 (70%) secured one of the top five picks. In contrast, two groups of 90% of black children and 89% of Hispanic children (over 45,069 out of a total of 71,349 applicants) received one of the top five choices.

76% of the city’s 9,767 white applicants scored one of the top five choices, while another 4,431 students who classified themselves as “multi-ethnic” got the worst results at just 68%. I saw. The citywide average was 83% for him.

“As you can see, it’s the Asian students who have lost the most,” said Yiatin Chu, co-founder of Parent Leaders for Accelerated Curriculum and Education, who heads the political club of the Asian Wave Alliance. said.

“I have faced many very unhappy families.”

Except 9 in the city Specialized high school – Applies to a separate application process — students may list up to 12 choices in order of preference.

Yiatin Chu leads the Asian Wave Alliance club.

However, 5,256 (or 7%) of applicants were unable to find an option and were deemed “unique” and designated at the DOE’s mercy. This is nearly 300 more “matchless” students than the year before, when he had nearly 3,000 more applicants to the city’s high schools.

About 12% of Asian and White students weren’t admitted to the high school of their choice this fall, while only 3% of Black students and 4% of Hispanic students were rejected.

The new system is based on complex mathematics method This enhances so-called equity for the city’s approximately 400 high schools. A student whose grades are in her high 90s can be in the best lottery group with students whose average grades are only in her 80s.

All students in the top group, representing 63% of this year’s applicants, are eligible to attend the most academically demanding schools.

Debbie Cross, a parent advocate on the citywide high school council, said the DOE was doing a poor job of preparing families for the new rules, and there was a lack of transparency throughout the process. I said that there is.

“I get a lot of calls from upset parents,” she said. “They don’t understand why their child was put in a school they hadn’t heard of. It’s not doing well and it’s not close to where they live.

“Some people are desperate to find Catholic schools. Some are considering private schools.

Alina Adams, another parent advocate and book author “I’m going to high school in New York.” Although she said she was “extremely sympathetic” to the Asian community, many Asian students and others use all 12 options in coveted schools and find them at least unattractive to their satisfaction. I think I was completely shut out because I couldn’t include the options.

“This system did exactly what it should have done,” she said. “I hate to generalize, but the bottom line is this: Many Asian students are very good and all have A’s. Many closed 12 schools that were meant only for children.

DOE officials also attributed the discrepancy to the fact that Asian and white students tend to rank more high-demand schools as applicants than students of other ethnicities. condemned.

The new admission system has caused extreme frustration for both parents and students.
The new admission system has caused extreme frustration for both parents and students.
JC Rice

“This administration is committed to increasing access to a quality education for all New York City students,” said DOE spokeswoman Nicole Brownstein. “This year, 75% of NYC high school applicants received an offer to one of their top three choices, and 50% received an offer to their top choice, both up from last year.

“prime minister [David] Banks remains committed to engaging families and communities across the city to gather feedback on how to improve this process over the next few years. ”

Additional reporting by Susan Edelman

Asian students lose out in New York City’s new school admissions system

Source link Asian students lose out in New York City’s new school admissions system

Back to top button